Subsurface Compaction – Queensland
- Soil compaction is caused by compression from machinery traffic or stock trampling, or soils may be naturally hard-setting.
- Poor root growth, swollen root tips and horizontal root growth can indicate a compacted layer (hardpan), usually between 10 and 40 cm.
- Compaction can be prevented or reduced by minimising vehicle traffic when the soil is wet, reducing the number of tillage operations and adopting controlled traffic farming.
- Amelioration of compaction in cracking soils is best achieved by using plant roots to promote the formation of cracks (biological ripping), and inducing drying and shrinking to form cracks. Cultivation when the soil is dry can also hasten the natural breakdown of clods.
Compacted subsurface layers may be an inherent feature of a soil, resulting from natural soil formation processes or be created by land management practices. Where land management is responsible, the most common causes of compaction are compression of the soil by stock or agricultural equipment when the soil is moist and loose. Compacted layers generally form between 10 and 40 centimetres.
A compacted soil lacks the interconnected air spaces that are essential to the movement of water, gases and plant roots. Crop yields are most affected by compaction in dry years when plant roots, unable to penetrate compacted layers, cannot access much-needed subsoil water and nutrients. Water use efficiency is also greatly reduced as rain or irrigation water is unable to penetrate past the compacted layers of soil to refill the subsoil. Cultivating compacted soils requires higher amounts of energy.
Detecting soil compaction
By examining the soil profile it is possible to identify a compacted soil layer because it is physically stronger (harder) and more dense than the soil above or below it. Compacted layers often have distinct massive or blocky appearance (figure 1) and are clearly defined horizontal layer that occurs between 10 and 40 cm.
Figure 1: (a) A dense compacted layer in yellow loamy sand at 15 – 30 cm (Photo by Noel Schocknecht, DAFWA); (b) A distinct compacted layer in a sandy loam, note fractures in hard pan through which roots preferentially grow.
In loam, sandy clay loam and clay soil, a hardpan will often fracture into large clods when dug up which can only be broken with some force. Plant indicators include; poor root growth, swollen root tips and horizontal root growth as roots try to force their way through compacted soils. Roots growing through compacted soils can be confined to macropores, soil fractures or be at a reduced density.
Hand probes are basically steel rods that are pushed into the soil by hand. Compacted layers can be detected because they are more difficult to push through than the soil above, and pushing also becomes easier once the rod is past the compacted zone. Testing with a hand probe needs to be done when the soil is wet to depth as many soils become hard when dry regardless of compaction status. Hand probes can be made from steel rod (about 8–10 mm diameter) or heavy gauge (3 mm) fencing wire about 40 cm long with one end looped to make a handle. Depth increments can be added.
A cone penetrometer (figure 2) works by the same principle as the hand probe except that it measures and records the force required to insert a standard sized cone into the soil profile. The penetrometer is inserted at a steady speed by hand and the instrument uses a gauge to measure the force (in mega-pascals (MPa) or kilopascals (KPa)) required to penetrate the soil at a given depth. The data are stored in a data logger and can then be downloaded and the strength of the soil profile assessed.
Penetration resistance can be related to crop root growth in wet soils close to the drained upper limit. In general, crop root growth starts to be restricted when the penetration resistance exceeds 1.5 MPa and is severely restricted at 2.5 MPa or more.
In autumn when the soil surface layers have been re-wet, the soil may still contain dry subsurface layers that resist a probe or penetrometer. Soils can be wet up before using a probe or penetrometer but it is essential to make sure the soil is wet deep enough to detect the compaction layer.
Figure 2: Cone penetrometer
Management of subsoil compaction
Ameliorating subsurface compaction can be difficult and costly. Therefore, it is best to minimise or prevent compaction as much as possible:
- Reduce the number of tillage operations conducted (preferably by adopting a zero tillage system).
- Reduce the area compacted by agricultural machinery by confining as many tillage and traffic operations to the same wheel tracks (a practice known as ‘controlled traffic farming’ or ‘tramline farming’—see Controlled Traffic factsheet).
- Avoid traffic and tillage when the soil is wet. Planting and weed control are two times when special care should be taken as these usually follow good rainfall.
- Test the soil before cultivation. If a clay soil can be rolled into a three millimetre diameter rod it indicates the soil is too wet and should not be cultivated.
- Use large diameter, narrower tyres. These compact less area than small wide tyres or dual tyres.
- Use flotation (low pressure) tyres if narrow tyres aren’t feasible.
- Restrict field bins and trucks to the edge of the paddock during harvest times.
Where subsurface compaction is already a problem a number of options are also available to repair compacted areas. These may be biological, mechanical or a combination of both.
While clay soils are most susceptible to compaction, many have an in-built mechanism to repair structural degradation because they swell and shrink on wetting and drying, which breaks up compacted soil. Crop roots can be used to promote this cracking, as they dry the soil out and promote the formation of cracks. The best response is gained when crops are rotated, so as to give different rooting patterns. This ‘biological ripping’ is a risk-free form of repairing soil compaction.
Cultivation when the soil is dry can also be used to hasten the natural breakdown of clods. However, it is important to ensure that cultivation is shallow so that deeper (and usually wetter) soil is not compacted. Before starting, the soil moisture to at least cultivation depth should be checked to ensure the soil is dry and that it will fracture rather than smear. Deep ripping should only be used on compacted soils as a last resort, as ripping moist to wet soil can cause further smearing and compaction.
Further Reading and References
Greacen EL and Williams J (1983) ‘Physical properties and water relations’, in Soils an Australian view point, CSIRO/Academic Press, pp 499-530.
Pillai UP and McGarry D (1999) ‘Structure repair of a compacted Vertisol with wet-dry cycles and crops’, Soil Science Society of America Journal, 63: 201-210.
Radford BJ, Yule DF, McGarry D and Playford C (2001) ‘Crop responses to applied compaction and to compaction repair treatments’, Soil and Tillage Research 61: 157-166.
Department of Environment and Resource Management (2009) Soil Compaction, Land Series Sheet L84, Queensland Government, Brisbane.
Tolmie P and Silburn M (2006) Soil limitations to water entry: Understanding restrictive soils layers, Land Series Sheet L40, Queensland Government, Brisbane.
The National Soil Quality Monitoring Program is being funded by the Grains Research and Development Corporation, as part of the second Soil Biology Initiative.
The participating organisations accept no liability whatsoever by reason of negligence or otherwise arising from the use or release of this information or any part of it.